How to Select Roast Color
What is roast color?
Like a piece of bread, raw coffee is mostly carbohydrates like starches and oils, although there are over 1600 chemical compounds in a single coffee bean.
When a slice of bread is toasted, it browns until it burns. Toasted light, you can taste the wheat. Toasted until burnt or very dark, you taste only the charred remains. So it is with our coffee bean (seed).
The flavor changes with the degree of roast. A Colombian tastes more like a Nicaraguan than like a Colombian coffee.
Roast color is a function of temperature and time. Relatively speaking, artisan roasters use variations of these controllable factors to create flavor. Roasting is a craft much like pottery is. Two potters using the same clay, the same glazes, and the same shapes will have different outcomes. Temperature + time in the kiln will determine what the craftsman’s effort will produce. So it is with coffee.
Generally, the coffee begins to roast at 405°F when the starches can get no hotter and they break down into simple sugars that carmelize at about 420°F. That is when the is pulled or dumped. It can take from 8-14 minutes to get to a color.
Between 420° and 475°F the color darkens until nothing is left to taste except burned plant matter!
Nuanced • Bright • Lively
In the lighter roasts (both light and medium), you can taste the nuance and impact of terroir. If you’re a lover, these coffees are your go-to. With a especially, the specific qualities unique to the coffee’s stand out. If you’re sticking with Vienna and French roasts (the darker beans), you have to work harder to tell the differences between origins. With light, it’s all there in the first sip.
For those of you that cup your coffee and take the time to taste every flavor, the lights and mediums are probably the roasts for you. Single Origins tend to be the best of this roast color – members of our Single Origin Coffee Club receive a bag of our fresh shipments each month.
Light Roast Recommendation:
Our Nicaragua Flor de Jinotega is a big hit. It’s nutty, chocolaty, smooth and sweet.
Nutty • Spicy • Balanced • Fruity
Roasted about 20 degrees Fahrenheit higher than the light, the color on a coffee bean shifts into a chocolate brown. As you move from the to the medium, the bright and lively morphs into a smoother, deeper, and more balanced mouth feel. In every sip of a , you’ll find that a certain mellowness and maturity prevails.
Medium Roast Recommendation:
Thanksgiving Coffee has many medium roasts that stand out, but our Fairtrade and Organic Mocha Java is a classic that we love more and more every time we brew it. This coffee has that balanced and nuanced flavor we referenced above, and was described as “paradoxically richly savory yet singingly sweet interpretation of the classic Mocha Java blend — complex, nuanced, multi-layered.” by CoffeeReview.com, where it scored 96 points.
Bold • Spicy • Chocolaty
The coffee bean color on our dark roast (sometimes called the ) is still more brown than black. You could compare it to the color of baker’s chocolate. When this coffee is freshly roasted, the beans will have a shiny coat of coffee oils on their surface. The greatest dark roast coffees will have hints of carbonization, but shouldn’t be described as smoky or toasty — we’ll leave those descriptors to the very dark roast.
Dark Roast Recommendation:
Our Beaujolais Blend consists of Vienna, French, and medium-roast Sumatra. The dark intensity of the French Roast complements the earthiness of the Sumatra, making this one of our most popular and enduring blends.
Very Dark Roast
Toasty • Smoky • Caramelized Sugars
Ah, the “French Roast.” This is the coffee that goes great with a splash of milk. The coffee bean color on our very dark roast is more black than brown, with rich and copious levels of surface oil. Roasted long and hot to produce deep carbony, smoky flavor notes. A well-made French roast will have caramelized sugar notes, licorice and roasted chestnut flavors, and a long wet (not ashy) finish.
Very Dark Roast Recommendation:
Our french roast recommendation is Noyo Harbor French, and it just so happens to be 20% while you’re reading this, in October, 2021! This is our signature Organic French roast. It’s Distinctly smoky with hints of jammy fruit, roasted nuts, and baker’s chocolate.